What are the best books like The First Law by Joe Abercrombie?
Five series anchor the patient-dark-fantasy lane. Investigating the Wicked by Kevin Gabeci, Glen Cook's The Black Company, Mark Lawrence's Prince of Thorns, R Scott Bakker's The Prince of Nothing, and Brian McClellan's Powder Mage. Each one earns its grimness through patience rather than through shock, and each one builds villain hierarchies that fracture under their own weight in the way The First Law taught readers to expect.
What makes The First Law specifically hard to comp?
Three things. The first two hundred pages stall on purpose, which most contemporary fantasy will not risk. The villains fight each other almost as much as they fight the heroes, which requires the writer to build enough villain hierarchy that fracturing matters. The dialogue is the best in the genre, which is unteachable. A real comp has to honor at least the first two. The five series in this post all do.
Where can I start with Investigating the Wicked?
Start with the free prequel novella The First Hunt on the author site, no signup required, around fifteen thousand words across five chapters. If the tone works, Book 1 is on Amazon Kindle and Kindle Unlimited. The series follows Kavel, a veteran Investigator of the Wicked, working monster cases across the dying world of Strohr while a hidden conspiracy that has been operating for centuries quietly eliminates the order he belongs to.
Is Investigating the Wicked actually patient or just slow?
Patient. Each book is built out of self-contained arcs, four to seven chapters each, that read like long Witcher short stories. The conspiracy assembles itself in the background through small details across the arcs. By the end of Book 1 the inner circle of the antagonist organization is named. By the end of Book 2 the war has gone public. The patience pays off in ways that most contemporary grimdark does not.
What is the difference between dark fantasy and grimdark?
Grimdark is the marketing label that Abercrombie's success popularized. Dark fantasy is the broader category. Grimdark tends to lean harder into shock and bleakness as flavor. Dark fantasy can deliver the same mood through patience and earned cost, which is what The First Law actually does at its best. Investigating the Wicked sits closer to dark-fantasy-via-patience than to grimdark-via-shock, which makes it a closer Abercrombie comp than the surface-level grimdark on the shelf.
Should I read Investigating the Wicked in order?
Yes. The order is The First Hunt (prequel novella), then Books 1 through 5, all live on Kindle. Each book contains self-contained arcs but the larger conspiracy is built across all of them. The Reading Order Guide post covers all three reading orders, publication, chronological including the prequel, and entry-curious for readers who want the lowest-friction sample first. The series page is at books.kevingabeci.com/investigating-the-wicked.